Alvin and Herman
The Plot Against AmericaHerman’s efforts to guide Alvin collide with Alvin’s resistance, ending in anger, injury, and separation.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Guardian’s Hope

A Guardian’s Hope
A second chance
Herman takes in Alvin after the deaths of Alvin’s parents and tries to redirect him from theft.
He secures him work with Abe Steinheim and urges him toward education and responsibility.
Care as duty
Herman believes sustained guidance can save his nephew from a destructive future.
The College Refusal

The College Refusal
A moral dispute
Abe Steinheim offers Alvin a route to college and future work, but Alvin rejects the obligation attached to the offer.
He accuses Herman of accepting exploitation when it benefits the family.
A break in trust
Alvin’s departure for Canada turns a dispute over work into a conflict of principle.
A Leg Lost

A Leg Lost
The price of service
Alvin fights in France and loses his left leg after a grenade explosion.
His injury ends his commando service and leaves him physically and emotionally devastated.
Herman’s helplessness
The guardian who wanted to prevent danger cannot protect Alvin from war.
The Household Caretaker

The Household Caretaker
Roles reverse
Philip helps Alvin with bandages, clothing, and his artificial leg as he begins to recover.
Herman urges Alvin to rebuild his life, but Alvin’s independence remains fragile.
A brief bond
The family’s practical care makes a temporary home for the wounded veteran.
The Rupture

The Rupture
Competing accounts
Herman condemns Alvin’s indifference to the violence against Jews, while Alvin says he lost his leg because Herman sent him to fight.
The argument becomes physical and destroys furniture as well as trust.
Separation
Alvin leaves again, and care cannot undo the resentment between uncle and nephew.
before 1940
early 1941
summer 1941
early 1942
October 1942